[Community] ... (Organisation)

wonderphone at posteo.de wonderphone at posteo.de
Mon Jun 2 23:37:22 CEST 2014

Hi all,

Am 01.06.2014 22:11 schrieb Dr. H. Nikolaus Schaller:
> Well, the key factor for speeding up all this is more demand for
> specific devices
> as we currently see. The statistics currently say differently.
> Approx. 30 preorders
> for GTA04A5 and ~370 for a Neo900 device. And this is the result of 6 
> months.

The GTA04 platform has the potential to sell enough devices to match 
the Fairphone success (50k devices) or even let their sales look small. 
My greater fear than the one of never selling such a number of phones is 
the one that "we" are not selling them, i. e. Goldelico does not produce 
them and the rest of the community is ignored completely. Once it 
becomes apparent that GTA04A5 or Neo900 are successful, a soft-spoken 
but hard-nosed manufacturer can fork the hardware development and offer 
the devices, say, 20% cheaper. That will put extra pressure on the 
quantities and prices of the community manufacturers. The community 
itself is replaced by a bunch of kids that "like" the devices on 
Facebook. They have a say in which color they want their devices in but 
nothing more. The monolithic (and also opaque) manufacturer will add 
some features to his software distribution that add convenience for the 
users and also valuable user information to the manufacturers databases.

Yes, Goldelico has made the community and is the strongest player in 
it. The openness that you, Nikolaus, have created is amazing. But the 
openness can be a weakness when it is not complemented by a 
well-organized community. That is why I am asking all these nerdy 
questions. I believe we need mechanisms in the community that make sure 
it grows because of its principles, stays always close to its ideals, 
and rewards those who have contributed in the past.


> Big companies are producing and shipping these quantities in less than 
> 1 minute.
> In other words: the products are not attractive for the masses. Even
> the masses of
> open source developers you can meet at FOSDEM.
> What can we do about that?
>> @ Nikolaus, dos, jOERG: How do you see the relationship of Goldelico 
>> and Neo900 UG within the OpenPhoenux community?
> I can only speak for Goldelico:
> * Goldelico has founded this OpenPhoenux community (see history [1])
> * and has supported it financially (e.g. by providing server space,
>    presenting the community at events like FOSDEM or LinuxTag)
> * Goldelico is seeing itself as a member of the community - side to
>    side with other developers - contributing the best it can to the 
> benefit
>    of all. E.g. developing devices, having them produced and making
>    them available (shop)
> * Goldelico is listening to ideas discussed on the mailing list to 
> decide
>    for new products Goldelico wants to offer. So this list is sort of 
> a
>    user (and potential user) forum.
> * Goldelico is helping (amongst others) to get the yearly OpenPhoenux
>    Hard- and Software Workshop organised: http://www.ohsw.org
>> Is there already anything scheduled that you want to do yourselves 
>> and do not want other guys from the community to mix with? Of course, 
>> the community has other things to do before, but what would you think 
>> if the community opened a shop that sells GTA04 devices?
> What would that be good for? The community member Goldelico
> already offers the GTA04 devices for sales
> http://shop.goldelico.com/wiki.php?page=GTA04A5
> and asks for donations:
> http://shop.goldelico.com/wiki.php?page=GTA04%3ADonation
> But of course there is plenty of room to increase the demand for GTA04 
> devices.
> The key issue is to address reach new potential users. And find out
> what they need, what the want, why they take something different
> why they don't participate here...
>> What would you think if the community managed to agree on a priority 
>> list of operating systems
> I think this is not a good idea since it is contrary to the current
> approach of providing
> devices that support multiple OS (which is quite unique).
> By giving one of them some preference, this would run the risk to
> optimise hardware
> for a specific OS and making trouble to others. OpenPhoenux devices
> have the target
> to support as many OS as possible. Contrary to those throw-away 
> devices of
> One of the key messages (second line of left column) of
> http://www.gta04.org says:
> "Runs Debian, SHR, QtMoko and whatever free and open distribution you 
> like."
> We should add Replicant there as well.
>> and used its funds to support programmers to go in that direction?
> Do you mean something like this?
> http://projects.goldelico.com/p/openphoenux/page/PaidDeveloper/
> BTW: some people did just recently give funds to further develop the 
> kernel
> and replicant. So there is already a little financing of activities,
> but it could
> be much more!
>> What if the community becomes demanding about the design of the 
>> devices, e. g. if people wanted /this/ module-something instead of 
>> another one?
> Hm. This requires some mechanism to do arbitration since there is 
> never
> not enough money to pay professionals to do it in quick time.
> Let's say it also this way: demanding something from somebody in an
> open source community is difficult and usually fails.
> So my approach to this should be: people who want something 
> differently
> should discuss their dreams here on the list. And those who feel more 
> capable
> of making dreams come true can comment on ideas t find ways to get 
> them
> really real.
>>> Momentum is important in
>>> these matters. I am happy to advise on business or marketing
>>> strategies if the project is headed in that direction. What is the
>>> development timeline? What still needs to be done technically?
>> To keep track of these questions easily and continuously an enhanced 
>> website would be helpful.
> That is what the Wiki is for:
> http://projects.goldelico.com/p/openphoenux/doc/
> Please feel free to create/maintain new pages with interesting 
> content.
> BR,
> Nikolaus
> [1]: http://projects.goldelico.com/p/gta04-main/page/News/
> [2]: http://projects.goldelico.com/p/gta04-main/page/Events/
> _______________________________________________
> Community mailing list
> Community at openphoenux.org
> http://lists.goldelico.com/mailman/listinfo.cgi/community
> http://www.openphoenux.org

More information about the Community mailing list